I've finally finished reading Total Archery: Inside the Archer by KiSik Lee (U.S. Head Coach) and Tyler Benner. It's a fantastic and detailed book that breaks down the steps of shooting into distinct chapters. Best of all it is bursting with large, full color images, just the kind of thing I've been missing in an archery book.
It is a book dense with information and for that reason I really spread out reading it. I started while I was at home re-cooperating from surgery and quickly became overwhelmed. Maybe because not only wasn't I able to shoot, but I could even stand up to go through the motions of what the book discussed. Or maybe I couldn't concentrate because of the percocet. Either way, I set aside the book until a short time after I returned to work, which led to the nice ritual of taking the 6:30 bus to campus, and sitting in the coffee shop for 30 minutes or so to read a chapter of Inside the Archer before work. It was perfect. And it left me un-rushed, letting everything really soak in. I took notes. I had questions. Things I didn't quite understand and things that didn't seem quite right and things I wanted to know more about. Which leads me to...
I got SO much more out of this book because I have an experienced coach who I trust to ask my questions to. I can't even imagine reading this book without such a guide. As someone who knows my shooting and knows my flaws and who also has immense experience in the sport, my coach answer my questions and explain what I didn't quite understand. He could also tell me which things I should just not worry about and which ones I should focus on now and which I could worry about later. I think reading and really trying to implement the techniques in this book without a coach, even one seen only occasionally would be a mistake, especially for a relatively new archer such as myself. Which bring me to...
I'm glad I read this book now, and not a year or even 6 months ago. Although, if it had been available, I probably would have. All the great pictures, the step-by-step break down of the shot, I wouldn't have been able to resist. I think I would have been overwhelmed by the information and much of it would have been talking about a final technique so far from where I was it would have meant very little, and would have seemed almost an impossible feat to achieve. As it is, I feel like I've gotten to a place where I have a fairly good understanding of the basics of what I should be doing (even if I'm not doing all of it) allowing me to really get lot out of the book, some of which can be applied now and some later. (And some maybe not at all - I like my wrist sling.) Knowing how far I've come in the past year, nothing seems quite so impossible as it did a year ago, even if it is far off in the future.
My biggest complaint about the book, was that it sometimes strives for poetry at the expense of clarity. I understand
this impulse and fall prey to it myself (as you must know if you regularly read this blog) but I feel it can be more easily
excused in fiction or creative non-fiction than in an explanatory text. When writing
about something difficult to understand, a method many people struggle
with, it's probably best to keep things a bit simpler and not let the words get in the way of the explanation. However, in the last chapter ("The Emotionality of Shooting") this style was perfect, and I wished there was even more time devoted to this.
Two things I really wish this book included:
An Index. OK, yes, I'm a librarian, I realized I might be a little biased. But the presence of an index is really one of the hallmarks of a good reference work and that is certainly what this is. It is a work that can be carefully read cover to cover, but almost certainly there will be parts you want to go back to, to hone in on certain details. The way the book is broken done step by step makes that easier, but there is a significant amount of cross referencing between chapters and a index would have been an improvement.
An Appendix listing the archers in the photos. I realize this book strives to portray "the archer" as anyone and everyone in the text and labeling the photos with the names of the archers could be a distraction to this endeavor, but an appendix with names would be nice.
Maybe these will be found in a second edition?